How to effect change: Alinsky versus Jesus

I came across a Wikipedia entry about Saul Alinsky's Rules for Radicals that summarized his teaching about social activism. Is it the way to go? It certainly seems a popular approach. Should Christians follow the same formula, or is there a distinctly Christian way to effect change? Here are some Bible verses lined up against Alinsky's rules. Does the Bible tell you to do the same thing? You decide.

Rules for Radicals (Wikipedia summary)
Bible (Bible.org)
“Power is not only what you have, but what the enemy thinks you have.” Power is derived from 2 main sources – money and people. “Have-Nots” must build power from flesh and blood.
The Lord says, “Wise people should not boast that they are wise. Powerful people should not boast that they are powerful. Rich people should not boast that they are rich. If people want to boast, they should boast about this: They should boast that they understand and know me. They should boast that they know and understand that I, the Lord, act out of faithfulness, fairness, and justice in the earth and that I desire people to do these things” (Jeremiah 9:23-24).
“Never go outside the expertise of your people.” It results in confusion, fear and retreat. Feeling secure adds to the backbone of anyone.
As he was walking by the Sea of Galilee he saw two brothers, Simon (called Peter) and Andrew his brother, casting a net into the sea (for they were fishermen). He said to them, “Follow me, and I will turn you into fishers of people!” They left their nets immediately and followed him (Matthew 4:18-20).
“Whenever possible, go outside the expertise of the enemy.” Look for ways to increase insecurity, anxiety and uncertainty.
Blessed are the merciful, for they will be shown mercy (Matthew 5:7).
“Make the enemy live up to its own book of rules.” If the rule is that every letter gets a reply, send 30,000 letters. You can kill them with this because no one can possibly obey all of their own rules.
For this is the way God loved the world: He gave his one and only Son, so that everyone who believes in him will not perish but have eternal life. 17 For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world should be saved through him (John 3:16-17).
“Ridicule is man’s most potent weapon.” There is no defense. It’s irrational. It’s infuriating. It also works as a key pressure point to force the enemy into concessions.
“You have heard that it was said to an older generation, ‘Do not murder,’ and ‘whoever murders will be subjected to judgment.’ But I say to you that anyone who is angry with a brother will be subjected to judgment. And whoever insults a brother will be brought before the council, and whoever says ‘Fool’ will be sent to fiery hell (Matthew 5:21-22).
“A good tactic is one your people enjoy.” They’ll keep doing it without urging and come back to do more. They’re doing their thing, and will even suggest better ones.
Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to them (Matthew 5:10).
“A tactic that drags on too long becomes a drag.” Don’t become old news.
So we must not grow weary in doing good, for in due time we will reap, if we do not give up (Galatians 6:9).
“Keep the pressure on. Never let up.” Keep trying new things to keep the opposition off balance. As the opposition masters one approach, hit them from the flank with something new.
Always rejoice, constantly pray, in everything give thanks. For this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus (I Thessalonians 5:16-18).
“The threat is usually more terrifying than the thing itself.” Imagination and ego can dream up many more consequences than any activist.
 “Do not judge so that you will not be judged. For by the standard you judge you will be judged, and the measure you use will be the measure you receive" (Matthew 7:1-2).
"The major premise for tactics is the development of operations that will maintain a constant pressure upon the opposition." It is this unceasing pressure that results in the reactions from the opposition that are essential for the success of the campaign.
…make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you (Matthew 28:19-20).
“If you push a negative hard enough, it will push through and become a positive.” Violence from the other side can win the public to your side because the public sympathizes with the underdog.
See that no one pays back evil for evil to anyone, but always pursue what is good for one another and for all (I Thessalonians 5:15).
“The price of a successful attack is a constructive alternative.” Never let the enemy score points because you’re caught without a solution to the problem.
Now when they heard this, they were acutely distressed and said to Peter and the rest of the apostles, “What should we do, brothers?” Peter said to them, “Repent, and each one of you be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit (Acts 2:37-38).
“Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.” Cut off the support network and isolate the target from sympathy. Go after people and not institutions; people hurt faster than institutions.
In everything, treat others as you would want them to treat you, for this fulfills the law and the prophets (Matthew 7:12).
Ideology and religion


Some of responses included:
  • "…religions focus on answering the world-view including afterlife and other things that are not in the materialistic world, whereas most ideologies focus on providing a world-view about the materialistic world."
  • "…ideology may mean any kind of action-oriented theory or any attempt to approach politics in the light of a system of ideas…[Religion] is also commonly regarded as consisting of the way people deal with ultimate concerns about their lives and their fate after death."
  • "Ideologies are active belief-systems. They need not be religious."

There were more responses, but they seemed to revolve around one general theme: the difference between ideology and religion is where we direct our faith. Both are based on assumptions we accept.

We know examples of religions, what are some examples of ideologies? Most -isms tend to be ideologies. One writer shared this statement that "There is good scientific evidence that political reasoning is based on innate, non-rational principles."

Why do we need to understand this? Those wishing to have an impact on this world must make a study of what motivates the people they seek to persuade. Not everyone will be convinced with a rational decision-making approach. Instead, those wishing to have an impact must account for the non-rational motivations that drive attitudes and decisions.
3 words to live by: Read, read, read

  • "Mattis was known to have had a personal library of over 7,000 books, and prompted the study of history for his troops through required reading lists of various history books for his officers before battle."
  • "He noted that his reading, 'doesn’t give me all the answers, but it lights what is often a dark path ahead.'"
  • "Mattis reportedly never owned a television set."

I've experienced some things in reading that may have helped deepen his intellect:
  • Books require you to follow an argument in close detail. A book's length allows it's author to dig into great detail and requires close and sustained attention from readers.
  • Novels allow authors to develop characters over time, requiring readers to navigate subtlety.
  • In this fast media age, books require us to give them time. We won't resolve things in the 30 minutes of a sitcom or the 2 hours of a movie. Instead, we have to display patience as we digest the book.

I have to think that reading discipline gave him an intellectual depth that helped him find his way through dilemmas. We often find ourselves on the horns of dilemmas, confronted by 2 alternatives neither of which lead to favorable outcomes. A deep intellect can help us find a 3rd way. Being able to find ways through dilemmas leads to a good reputation. Some points from the article:
  • "Beyond the bravado, and tough wartime rhetoric, Mattis was known to be an intellectual among the military’s upper ranks, a thoughtful and well-read commander, emphasizing (perhaps in a monkish way) the study of both history and philosophy."
  • "Mattis emphasized that his Marines always take a reasoned approach to the battlefield"
  • "Mattis’ ethics ensure that he has always told politicians and higher-ups his honest views on often thorny political or military issues."
If you build it, will they come?

The National Wood Flooring Association launched an online university to prepare people for certifications in wood flooring. Why did they do that? Apparently, not enough young people are taking up the trades. I don't think that means an industry is dying. It may mean perceptions of the industry by potential skilled workers need to be updated.

Demand and supply factors in the shortage of skilled labor.
  • Demand: Workforce in the trades is aging out.
  • Supply: Young people still want to go to college instead of take up a trade.

The trades are concerned their careers aren't as flashy as others. NWFA University offers digital badges as credentials in response.

Flashiness isn't the cure-all, however. Saying college isn't necessary isn't the solution either. There are benefits from going to college that tradespeople can gain. Rather, there needs to be a way to help people find a balance. What incentives are there, for example, to encourage working tradespeople to take college courses on the side? A degree can be had without going into debt while fixing the labor shortages in the trades.
Hallelujah Chorus etiquette: Stand or sit?

It's that time of year to go to a Messiah concert, and you'll have to make a decision about the Hallelujah chorus: stand or stay seated?

  • The most popular story is that "King George II, attending the London premiere of 'Messiah' in March of 1743, was so moved by the 'Hallelujah’' that he stood up - and if the king stands, everybody stands." The more cynical theorized the king had to go to the bathroom and was waiting for intermission, ready to sprint.
  • People stood for other numbers as well, so the Hallelujah Chorus tradition remains from something that was more common.
  • The sacred nature of the words moved some people to stand on reflex. They may have felt like they were in church listening to hymns.

Here's what some people advise:

There are a couple of solutions:

So what to do if there's no guidance in the program or from the stage? It may be a situational thing.
  • I attended one that was performed in a light way, the choir members dressed in Christmas costumes and flashing signs with the words. The Hallelujah Chorus was merely one selection among other Christmas music, sacred and secular. Not many people stood for that one.
  • Another performance was a more traditional performance of Messiah. Everyone stood for that one.

Either way, the advice to include consideration of other people's enjoyment of the performance is always in season.
The star of Bethlehem. Out for last year's Christmas season, this may be worth your time to read over the coming holidays. Why would it be important for the average Christian? One way to look at it is contextualization. In the spirit of the apostle Paul's becoming all things to all men, this age fancies itself enlightened through science. If so, your friends will be interested in factoids about cometography and the reasonableness of seeing the star as a significant natural phenomenon. Why suggest it was a natural phenomenon? It could be a way to direct conversation to God's control of nature, one element of an apologetic argument.

===========
The Great Christ Comet: Revealing the True Star of Bethlehem by Colin R. Nicholl on Amazon (hardcover | Kindle) on Barnes and Noble (hardcover | Nook)

Is crowdfunding like grant management?

Apparently, Steve Wozniak has stopped participating in crowdfunding projects because he can't see how the money is being spent. Among other things he said in an interview is this: "I’ve actually turned away from self-funding for now. Kickstarter and Indiegogo and those sort of things…You never get to see their accounting. You never get to see how they used your money. It’s not like a real open company."

This makes me think of applying for and managing grants and donations. The funding sources want to see how their money is spent, and they get irritated if money goes to overhead costs rather than direct costs involved in moving the project forward. Many funding sources I've encountered put conditions on use of the funds, including reporting requirements. Excluded items can include overhead costs like marketing and office equipment.

That makes sense, because that kind of spending can become excessive, so funding sources want some kind of accounting. There are some who push back because groups like non-profits that depend on grants can be hindered by not being able to use money where they see the most need.

What have you seen that is a win-win solution, and how can it be applied to crowdfunding?